Analysis authors sources to show how used but few quotes doesnt show how used authors sources 50% of grade provides many pertinent examples provides some examples mentions authors ignores authors of authors use of evidence of authors use of evidence use of evidence use of evidence. All quotations or examples clearly demonstrate and support the claim of the paper. Evaluation rubric for written summaries of journal articles. Title and illustration are poorly done or do not relate to the story.
Winner of the pulitzer prize winner of the pen robert w. Rubric for literary analysis student will interpret and analyze a work of literary merit. The organization, elements of summaries, grammar, usage, mechanics, and spelling of a written piece are scored in this rubric. The book tinkers follows the history of george washington crosby on his deathbeda hospital bed in the living room of the house he constructed himself. Rubric of a text analysis for younger learners there are 4 levels, each using a different smiley face. The literary analysis rubric is selfexplanatory, but here are some things you may want to prompt your students with before the writing begins or between the first draft and next draft. Teaching about rubrics before using the rubric strategy, students will need to become familiar with the concept of rubrics.
To this list ought to be added paul hardings devastating first book, tinkers. Rubric scoring guide for literary analysis and criticism. Discussion of themes and motifs in paul hardings tinkers. Category exceeds standards meets standards approaches standards comments focus or thesis statement. The story follows the main character, george washington crosby, as he lay dying. If you are looking for a great rubric book that isnt written like a textbook then this is it. At once heartbreaking and life affirming, it is an elegiac meditation on love, loss, and the fierce beauty of nature. Their new story will be evaluated on their description, thoughtfulness, creativity, and analysis from the original story based on this rubric. The honors council has chosen the above outcome as our program assessment objective for this academic year.
When rubric criteria are tied to learning outcomes. Students are expected to consider the role of syntax, diction, the effect of voice, tone, and imagery in a work of literary merit. Organization does the text follow a typical chronological plot pattern, or is it more elaborate and unconventional. It will surprise few readers of tinkers, a pulitzer prizewinning first novel, that paul harding was a student of marilynne robinson, who won a.
Capitalization grammatical conventions for grade 10 1. Rubric scoring guide for literary analysis and criticism writing grammatical conventions for grade 9 1. It is a great way to promote the love of reading in your classroom. Rubric aligned to the 20192020 scoring guidelines for the prose fiction analysis freeresponse question of the ap english literature and composition exam. These elements include identifying important themes, comparing and contrasting stories and authors, defining writing techniques and devicesand anything else. You can then use this rubric as is or customize its content to suit your needs. Rosie improved upon a rubric that i had shared with her by rethinking the categories, and creating very detailed guidelines for each section.
Evaluation rubric for written summaries of journal articles criteria outstanding very good good satisfactory unacceptable appropriate details judicious choice of details maximizes interest and understanding all relevant details presented, but details not critical to understanding omitted enough critical details presented for understanding. Tinkers, small novel contrasting life with death, body with soul, time with eternity, man with nature is an attempt to understand and explore what life and humanity is. Tinkers is about the legacy of consciousness and the porousness of identity from one generation the next. Formulates a focused, arguable, and defendable thesis. Analysis is the process of breaking complex topics or issues into parts to gain a better understanding of them. The literary analysis paragraph rubric literary analysis is a type of writing where a writer literally breaks a story down to its most basic elements and then analyzes how and why those elements work in that particular story. Tinkers won the 2010 pulitzer prize for fiction, and. As time collapses into memory, he travels deep into his past where he is reunited with his father and relives the wonder and pain of his impoverished new england youth. Rethinking rubrics in writing assessment maja wilson.
Plagiarism results in a 0 for this portion of the assignment. Title and illustration clearly relate to the story. Thesis presents a strong assertion or claim, is tightly focused. Your essay should present a clear analytical interpretation of one aspect of the text at hand. After reading the inspiring book the book whisperer this summer i decided to make some changes to my reading instruction this year. If anybody who is in writing must analyse the way harding writes. They will use adequate detail to show their analysis of the character, setting, or event. Thus you will need to generate a rubricperhaps with the aid of your students. Universal rubric for literary analysis ela common core. To analyze your rubric, click on the addedit results button, which is located on the upper righthand side of your window. A rubric is a type of scoring guide that assesses and articulates specific components and expectations for an assignment. The items listed below are intended to provide feedback in a number of critical areas which your instructor deems important to your analysis. Students may be required to consider the use of symbolism, allegory, and allusion in the work. It is a short read yet it is full of great information.
Tinkers summary supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. Materials created by new visions are shareable under a creative commons attributionnoncommercialsharealike 4. Analysis and discussion of characters in paul hardings tinkers. Literary analysis rubric ela common core lesson plans. This study guide consists of approximately 20 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of tinkers. Inquiry is a systematic process of exploring issues, objects or works through the collection and analysis of evidence that results in informed conclusions or judgments.
During the course of this unit, you will be expected to write one literary analysis essay focusing on one or more, depending on the option you choose of the short stories weve read in clas. Paul harding won the pulitzer prize for writing tinkers. Apostrophes grammatical conventions for grade 11 1. Working in assessment this is the best book i have found for rubrics yet. Alfie kohn, author of the case against standardized testing this book will create the conversations educators desperately needabout accurate assessment, quality in writing, and informed teaching. You presented the who, what, where, when, why, and how of the story. Literary analysis paragraph rubric the crafted word. The student will employ critical thinking and analytical skills in accomplishing the honors project. George washington crosby chronicles his own life from boyhood to the time he currently lays in the hospital bed in his dining room, surrounded by his wife, daughters. The central character in the novel is george washington crosby, who, at the beginning of the story, is lying on his deathbed with. Students will write a story using the character, setting, or event they describe or evaluate. Once you have graded your students with this rubric, you can come to this analysis page and enter the number of students that received each rating. Robinson swept us into the thoughts of a dying old man with deep spiritual resources. Tinkers paul harding, 2009 bellevue literary press 192 pp.
It will surprise few readers of tinkers, a pulitzer prizewinning first novel, that paul harding was a student of marilynne robinson, who won a pulitzer for gilead in 2005. Literary analysis rubric did i demonstrate and understanding of the assignment by. The literary analysis 10point rubric for clarity and. Offers accurate analysis of the document demonstrates only a minimal understanding of the document reiterates one or two facts from the document but does not offer any analysis or interpretation of the document knowledge of historical context shows evidence of thorough knowledge of period in which source was written. The story follows the main character, george washington crosby. As time collapses into memory, he travels deep into his past where he is reunited with his father and relives the wonder. The writers ethos is one of confidence and competence. One of the primary themes of the novel is the rite of passage of death. Ks 500level classes outstanding a range above average b range competent c range insufficient d to f range writers approach the analysis presents fresh and defensible insights into the work being analyzed. Essay displays insightful understanding and analysis of. Scoring rubric for critical analysis points possible.
The book youre about to read is not only a superb analysis of rubrics but a lesson in how to apply careful thinking to classroom practice. It is written for a more academic audience meaning professors but the information can easily be adapted to any rubric. Since rubistar is free, supported by a grant from the u. The thesis statement clearly and effectively connects the purpose and target audience of the essayarticle to the writing techniques to be analyzed. Use this rubric to grade writing samples, essays, short passages, or journal entries. Rubric for literary analysis papers san jose state. Its contemplative, brimming with melancholia an elegy for passing time, father son relationship and determinism of blood ties. At the end of the semester, please complete the rubric on the back. Writing an analysis paragraph is a bit like going to the doctor. This is a rubric for a literary analysis that breaks down the points into 10 specific skills, including introduction conclusion paragraphs, thesis, topic sentences, textual evidence, analysis, style, organization, grammar, mla, and following directions. Confined to bed in his living room, he sees the walls around him begin to collapse, the windows come loose from their sashes, and the ceiling plaster fall off in great chunks, showering him with a lifetime of debris. Tinkers by paul harding meet your next favorite book. First, you may want to examine some grading rubric resources see box, rubric resources for. Grading rubric for the childrens picture storybook 3 2 1 cover title and illustration on cover clearly relate to the story and entice readers to pick up the book.
1406 896 394 157 1226 267 800 1237 835 681 1389 332 159 1636 905 1489 1314 724 641 694 1102 68 821 1146 279 721 546 1342 867 719 33 469 834 462 918 444 1105